The Rope Can’t Tell
The Ringelmann effect
Put more people on a job and each one tends to do less.
Max Ringelmann measured it with a rope in the 1880s: 85.3 kg a man alone, 61.4 in a group of fourteen. The rope only reports the total.
Pull four times here and see what company does to you.
Scroll to haul After Ilya Repin, Barge Haulers on the Volga, 1870 to 1873.
Grand-Jouan, France, 1882.
Max Ringelmann is testing engines.
Horses. Oxen. Machines. Men.
He hardly draws a line between them.
His test is a rope, five meters long.
One end runs to a recording dynamometer.
The other end is yours.
You’re the student.
His students averaged 85.3 kilograms.
There were 28 of them, each pulling alone.
Now he adds men.
If effort simply added up, eight would pull 8.00.
Two men: 1.86
Three men: 2.55
Four men: 3.08
Five men: 3.50
Six men: 3.78
Seven men: 3.92
Eight men: 3.92
The eighth man added nothing.
That table has been quoted for about a century.
He never said which task it came from.
A German summary in 1927 said rope, and the rope stuck.
His measured rope was kinder.
Alone: 85.3 kg a man.
In sevens: 65.0.
In a fourteen: 61.4.
Nine.
Ten.
Eleven is how many Ilya Repin painted.
Barge Haulers on the Volga, 1870 to 1873.
A critic stood in front of it in 1873.
“A living haulage machine,” he wrote. Vladimir Stasov.
Then he looked closer.
“Dissembling a little and contriving to carry less.”
The tall soldier, puffing his pipe.
This one is filling his pipe as he walks,
his shoulder resting on the man beside him.
You can see them.
The rope can’t.
A dynamometer reads one number.
It has no idea who is in it.
Take your place.
Would anyone have noticed you let go?
The rope can’t tell.
Ringelmann blamed timing:
“the lack of simultaneity of their efforts.” Ringelmann, 1913.
Every man peaks, just not together.
Crews already knew the fix.
They sang.
But he’d seen something a song can’t fix.
Prisoners turning a flour mill:
“each man, trusting in his neighbor to furnish the desired effort, contented himself by merely following the movement of the crank.” Ringelmann, 1913, translated by Kravitz and Martin.
In 1974, a team in Massachusetts took the timing away.
They blindfolded each puller
and said other men were on the rope behind him.
They were faking it.
He was pulling alone, and his pull still dropped.
Ten men are behind you.
They’re still back there.
Now they let go.
It’s just you.
Take off the blindfold.
There was never anyone behind you.
They’re paint.
Every reading in this room came from your two thumbs.
You skipped at least one pull, so this rope has no reading for you.
- Alone: no pull
- With the crew: no pull
- Blindfolded, “ten men” behind: no pull
- Blindfolded, alone: no pull
Scroll back and take all four, or carry on. The research doesn’t need your thumbs.
A low number doesn’t mean a lazy man.
Stasov’s next hauler is wiping his brow,
“terribly ill and exhausted.”
The needle can’t say why.
What changes it is being heard.
In 1981, blindfolded people shouted less
when they thought others were shouting too.
Given their own microphones, they shouted just as loud in a group as alone. Williams, Harkins and Latané.
Give every man his own dial.
Now the rope can tell.
Far off, Repin left a steamer.
The rope’s replacement, trailing smoke.
New crews are on new ropes now.
0 of 4 pulls recorded.